Sell Your House Fast in Bay Shore, NY. Closing Date You Choose.

Selling a house in Bay Shore, whether it is near the Maple Avenue ferries or next door in West Bay Shore? Send the address and we can usually tell you whether we can make an offer.

  • ✓ Cash offer within one business day
  • ✓ Your closing date, your choice
  • ✓ No agent commission to you
  • ✓ We buy as-is
  • ✓ Closing through a New York attorney or title company

Prefer to talk first? Call us at (833) 330-1625

Bay Shore house on your mind? Tell us where it is and what shape it is in.

Written offer within one business day. No obligation.

Your information is kept private and never sold to third parties.

Eagle Cash Buyers Google reviews BBB Accredited Business

Getting your offer ready...

  • A+BBB rating
  • 4.5from 40 Google reviews
  • 1,000+transactions completed
  • 43states we buy in

Oren Sofrin, as quoted inMSNYahoo FinanceGOBankingRatesBiggerPockets

Eagle Cash Buyers buys houses in Bay Shore, New York, for cash, in whatever condition they are in, when the numbers work. Send the address and we can usually say whether we can make an offer. A written offer follows within one business day, and most sales close in 21 to 42 days, or later if you need more time.

What People Say About Working With Us

Amber MotaRated 5 out of 5
Quick and efficient! I highly recommend!
Gannon HallRated 5 out of 5
I have worked with Eagle Cash Buyers on several deals both personal and investments. They work well with swiftness and professionalism. Their team is friendly and easy to work with!
Nancy RectorRated 5 out of 5
I had a great experience and they are wonderful to work with. Very understanding with my goals.
Todd KillianRated 5 out of 5
Experienced and trustworthy! It has been great to work with Oren from Eagle Cash Buyers.

4.5 from 40 reviews on Google · more reviews · read them all on Google

Hear It From Sellers

Sellers we bought from, in their own words. Under a minute and a half.

Who You Are Dealing With

  • 43 states, New York among them. We are not a one-county operator and not a lead broker who sells your details on.
  • 4.5 stars across 40 Google reviews. Not all of them are five stars. You can read them yourself before you call.
  • A named company with a named founder. Who we are, and Oren Sofrin, who founded and runs it.
  • Closings handled through a New York attorney or title company. Settlement happens the way any New York sale does, with a recorded deed.
  • No obligation. An offer is an offer. Turn it down and nothing happens.

Bay Shore Homeowners We Help

Bay Shore sellers come with very different houses and reasons. Some are handling an inherited home in Suffolk County, some own a rental, and some simply want to sell without listing and without repairs.

A House That Needs Work

You do not have to fix, paint or clean before selling. We can buy a house in any condition when the numbers work, and the price we offer reflects the condition we find, so you can skip the contractors and the weeks of repairs.

An Inherited Home

If a parent or relative left you a house in Bay Shore, you may be dealing with distance, an estate and a house nobody lives in. Tell us where things stand and we can explain how a cash sale could fit. Probate questions go to an attorney.

Related guide: How to Sell an Inherited House

A Rental With Tenants In Place

You do not need to wait for a lease to end or ask anyone to move out. We buy houses with tenants in them. A lease generally passes to the buyer at closing, though what happens next depends on the lease terms.

Related guide: Selling a Rental Property With Tenants

Behind on Payments or Taxes

Back taxes, a lien or missed mortgage payments make a regular listing harder. A cash sale can move on your timeline, and the mortgage payoff, liens and prorated taxes can be paid from the sale proceeds when the price covers them. We are not attorneys, so a lawyer should confirm your options.

Selling Before a Move or Divorce

When a move, a job change or a divorce sets the schedule, a sale that closes on a date you pick takes pressure off. Most sales close in 21 to 42 days, or later if you need more time. At Eagle, we ask everyone on the deed to take part when we present the offer.

Related guide: Selling a House During Divorce

A Mobile Home on Its Own Land

If you own a mobile home and the land under it, send us the address and the details. We can usually say whether we can make an offer, if the numbers work.

Tell us about the property and you will hear back within one business day. Send it on a weekend and that means the next business day. There is no pressure either way.

Get My Cash Offer

What the Numbers Actually Look Like - Cash Sale vs. Listing vs. Instant-Offer Programs

Sellers in Bay Shore are right to ask about the net rather than the headline offer price. On a typical listing, agent commission, closing costs, the New York Transfer Tax and repairs can all come out before you see a dollar. Here is how the three paths compare.

Cost or FactorEagle Cash Buyers (Cash Sale)Traditional Listing (Agent)Instant-Offer Program (iBuyer)
Agent CommissionNone - $0Negotiable, not fixed. For illustration only, a typical 5% to 6% commission on a $676,700 sale is about $33,800 to $40,600Usually none, though a service fee often applies
Repairs Before SaleNone - we buy as-isOften paid by you before listing, or given back in price, and buyers' inspections often ask for moreOften deductions for repairs after the inspection
New York Transfer TaxState rate $4.00 per $1,000 (0.40%). Your share is paid from your proceeds, as set out in the purchase agreement and shown on your settlement statementThe same tax appliesThe same tax applies
Seller Closing CostsWe pay the closing costs, except your share of any transfer tax. Your mortgage payoff, any liens and prorated property taxes are paid from the sale proceeds.Title, recording and closing fees, plus prorations; amounts vary by contractA service fee set by each platform
Days to CloseMost close in 21 to 42 days, or later if you need more time; you pick the dateWeeks on the market, then weeks more to close, and a financed buyer's loan can still fall throughSet by each platform, and instant-offer programs buy only in some areas
Showings and InspectionsNo public showings. Walkthroughs and any reinspection are as set out in the agreementMultiple showings, buyer inspection, possible renegotiation after inspectionUsually a company inspection, often with repair deductions
Financing Contingency RiskNo buyer mortgage contingency. Other contract terms still applyBuyer financing can fall through weeks into the processLow risk, but platform rules apply
Condition RequiredWe buy as-is - no updates neededBuyers and agents expect move-in or near-move-in condition for top dollarVaries - iBuyers often exclude significant distress

Your actual net depends on your loan payoff, prorations and contract terms. We walk through it with you before you sign anything. Instant-offer terms vary by company and change often.

Skip the listing process. Close on your schedule, in Bay Shore, with no agent commission and the closing costs covered, apart from your share of any transfer tax.

See What We'd Pay

An Example From a Real Call

One homeowner had a family member make the first call after sending in an inquiry. Our acquisition manager noticed the inquiry was in the owner's name, so he asked whether she could take part before discussing the property. He explained that the first call is basic: a chance to learn about the property and the condition it is in. A three-way call was set up for when the owner was home.

Three Steps, From First Call to Closing

A single-family house

Sellers ask whether a cash sale is complicated. Usually it is not: we work with New York attorneys and title companies who coordinate the paperwork, and you sign in person or remotely, as the closing attorney or title company arranges. Here is how it runs.

1

Tell Us About Your Property

Call us at (833) 330-1625 or fill out the form on this page. We ask a few basic questions: the address, the condition and your situation. No obligation, no hard pitch. Tell us what you know about the roof, plumbing, foundation and any past damage. See how our closing process works, start to finish.

2

Receive Your Cash Offer Within One Business Day

We look at the property, recent comparable sales in Bay Shore, and the repair costs, which we take off the price rather than asking you to do the work. You get a written cash offer with no agent commission. It shows the price, the contingencies and your estimated net before you sign. To weigh it against a traditional sale, our New York page sets out what a listing costs.

3

Pick Your Closing Date and Get Paid

Once you accept, we open title with the closing attorney or title company, who handles the title search, the loan payoff and the closing paperwork. The New York Transfer Tax and every other cost are shown on your settlement statement before closing. Most sales close in 21 to 42 days, depending on when the title work clears, or later if you need more time; you pick the date. Anything that could change the price after we agree is written into the agreement, so you can see it before you sign.

Bay Shore Housing Market - What the Numbers Say

Zillow's Home Value Index put the typical Bay Shore home at $676,700 in August 2026, 4.9% higher than a year earlier.

$676,700
Typical Home Value (Zillow Home Value Index, August 2026)
+4.9%
Year-Over-Year, Zillow Home Value Index, August 2026

A typical-value figure reflects mid-priced homes across the whole area, not the condition of any one house. A house that needs work, or that has tenants or a lien attached, may sell for less than that figure.

Selling on the open market usually means agent commission, often between 5% and 6%, plus repairs and showings. A cash sale to Eagle skips the listing and the showings, so you can compare the two on net proceeds and on time, if the numbers work.

Source: Zillow Home Value Index, August 2026. The figures describe Bay Shore as a whole and do not set the value of any one house.

How to Check Out Any Cash Buyer in Bay Shore

These questions apply to us too. Any buyer should answer them plainly.

  1. Ask for proof of funds. A real buyer can show a bank letter or statement quickly. Ask us the same question. If we assign the contract, ask the closing buyer for theirs too.
  2. Ask whether they intend to assign the contract. Our answer: Eagle may purchase the property itself or, if the purchase agreement permits, assign its contractual rights to another investor or purchasing entity. Any assignment right is stated in the agreement before you sign. Assignment itself is not the problem. What matters is whether the right to assign is disclosed, whether the buyer stays accountable under the agreement, and whether the closing structure and deadlines are clear before you sign. Ask any buyer to put those terms in writing.
  3. Never pay anything up front. No application fee, no inspection fee, no processing fee. If money is moving from you to the buyer before closing, stop.
  4. Look the company up. Search the buyer's name in the business registry of the state where it was formed, and check that it is active. Eagle Cash Buyers, LLC is registered in Ohio.
  5. Get the whole offer in writing before you sign, including who pays closing costs and what happens if the buyer walks.

Where We Buy Houses in Bay Shore and Suffolk County

We buy across Bay Shore, neighbouring West Bay Shore and the rest of Suffolk County, when the numbers work.

Neighborhoods and areas in Bay Shore

Maple Avenue and the Fire Island Ferries

The Fire Island ferry terminals sit at the southern end of Maple Avenue, across the canal from the Bay Shore Marina. If your house is in this part of Bay Shore, send us the address and we can usually say whether we can make an offer.

West Bay Shore

West Bay Shore is a neighbouring hamlet, separated from Bay Shore by the village of Brightwaters. It is also in the Town of Islip and Suffolk County, and we buy houses there as well.

Near the Bay Shore LIRR Station

The Bay Shore station is on the Long Island Rail Road's Montauk Branch, with trains west toward Babylon and New York City. Being near the station is one thing a buyer may weigh, but we buy houses here in any condition when the numbers work.

Neighborhood details are drawn from public sources, including en.wikipedia.org. Conditions vary from house to house.

Main ZIP code: 11706

We also buy in nearby communities

Ready to Sell Your Bay Shore Home - Without the Commission or the Repairs?

We buy as-is for cash in Bay Shore and across Suffolk County, so there is nothing to fix or clean up first. There are no repairs to schedule, no agent commission and no buyer mortgage contingency. You get a written offer within one business day and a closing date you choose, handled through a New York attorney or title company.

Eagle Cash Buyers Google reviewsEagle Cash Buyers - BBB Accredited Business

We buy houses in Bay Shore, NY and throughout Suffolk County. Cash offer within one business day. Most sales close in 21 to 42 days, or later if you need more time. No obligation to accept.

Bay Shore and Suffolk County Seller Questions

Cash Sale Questions From Bay Shore and Islip Town Homeowners

Closing, costs, liens, inherited homes and mobile homes, answered briefly for Suffolk County.

Who pays closing costs when I sell my Bay Shore house to you?

We pay the closing costs on a sale to us, except your share of any transfer tax, and the purchase agreement sets this out. Eagle does not charge you an agent commission on a direct sale to us. Your mortgage payoff and any liens, delinquent taxes, HOA or association balances, agreed prorations and other seller obligations are deducted from your proceeds when applicable. The closing professional provides a settlement statement showing the charges and credits before closing. Transfer, deed, conveyance or similar taxes vary by state and locality. For a sale in Bay Shore: state rate $4.00 per $1,000 (0.40%), subject to the purchase agreement.

How fast can I close on my Bay Shore house?

We make a written offer within one business day of getting the details. Most sales close in 21 to 42 days, or later if you need more time, and you pick the date. The closing is handled through a New York attorney or title company, and you can sign in person or remotely.

How does Eagle decide what to offer on a Bay Shore house?

We look at the condition of the house, what similar homes in the area are worth and what any work would cost. Send the address and a few details and we can usually say whether the numbers work for an offer.

Can I sell my Bay Shore house with a lien or back taxes on it?

Often, yes. Delinquent property taxes and many recorded liens can be paid from the sale proceeds at closing, provided there is enough equity and the required payoff or release can be obtained. The title search or other closing review will identify items that must be paid, released or otherwise resolved. A disputed lien, an unavailable payoff or debts exceeding the available proceeds can delay or prevent closing unless the issue is resolved or the creditor agrees to another arrangement. Tell us what you know upfront so the closing professional can investigate it early.

Do I have to go through probate before I can sell an inherited house in Bay Shore?

It depends on how title was held and New York law. Property held in the deceased owner's name alone may require probate or another estate procedure before anyone has authority to sign a deed. Property held in a trust or with survivorship rights may pass outside probate. A probate or estate attorney licensed in New York should confirm who has authority and which procedure applies. We can evaluate the property and make an offer while that is being established, but we cannot close until someone has legal authority to sign.

Do I still have to make disclosures if I sell my Bay Shore house as-is?

Selling a property as-is does not automatically eliminate disclosure obligations under applicable federal, state or local law. Tell us what you know about the roof, plumbing, electrical system, foundation, environmental conditions and any past damage or repairs so we can evaluate the property accurately and address known issues in writing before you sign. New York sellers commonly complete a Property Condition Disclosure Statement, which may apply to your sale. A real estate attorney licensed in New York can confirm which disclosures apply.

Will Eagle Cash Buyers buy my house itself, or assign the contract?

Eagle may purchase the property itself or, if the purchase agreement permits, assign its contractual rights to another investor or purchasing entity. Any assignment right is stated in the agreement before you sign. The agreement also states the price, closing date or timeline, contingencies and other material terms. The closing is handled by the attorney or title company used for the transaction.

Can selling my Bay Shore house to you stop a foreclosure?

A sale may help avoid a foreclosure sale if it closes in time and the proceeds are enough to satisfy the required payoff, or if the lender gives written approval to accept less. In New York, a foreclosure generally goes through the court. We cannot promise to stop or postpone a foreclosure; that depends on the lender or servicer, the court, the timing and whether the transaction closes. Contact us as early as possible and bring every notice you have so we can usually tell you whether our expected timeline appears workable. A HUD-approved housing counselor or an attorney licensed in New York can explain your legal options and deadlines. At Eagle, we can help only if there are at least 3 weeks before the auction date and you can send paperwork quickly and help the attorney or title company close fast. Our New York page explains how the foreclosure process generally works in the state.

Do you buy mobile homes in Bay Shore?

We buy mobile homes only when they are sold together with the land they sit on. If you own the house and the land in Bay Shore, send us the address and we can usually say whether we can make an offer.

Do I have to make repairs before selling my Bay Shore house?

No. We can buy a house in any condition when the numbers work, so you do not have to repair, clean out or stage it. Tell us honestly what you know about the house, because the offer is based on its condition.

Who has to be on the call when you present the offer?

At Eagle, our policy is to have everyone on the deed and every decision maker on the call when we present the offer, so they can decide together whether to move forward. A spouse, relative or attorney can make the first contact for you.

Is selling for cash right for my Bay Shore home?

It depends on what matters most to you. A listing may bring a higher price if the house is in good shape and you can wait, while a cash sale is about speed, fewer steps and no repairs. Compare the net proceeds and the timeline for both, and ask an attorney or tax adviser about your own situation.

Eagle Cash Buyers is not a law firm, title company or tax advisor. This information is general and is not legal, title or tax advice. Laws, procedures and transaction costs vary by state and locality, and the purchase agreement and closing documents control each transaction.

Oren Sofrin

Reviewed by Oren Sofrin, Founder and CEO of Eagle Cash Buyers

Oren has more than ten years in real estate, and he and the Eagle team have completed over 1,000 transactions. His market commentary has been quoted by MSN, Yahoo Finance, GOBankingRates and BiggerPockets. Last reviewed November 2026.

CallGet my cash offer