Asked in Florida
Why Houses Are Not Selling in Florida Right Now
This is one of the most asked questions attached to selling a house in Florida,
and the answer is not the one most sellers expect. It is mostly not about your asking price.
The market has genuinely turned
- 206,508 homes for sale statewide in August 2026, with about
six months of supply. Six months is the level at which a market stops
favoring sellers.
- 73 days to sell the median home.
- Only 10.9% sold above the asking price.
- One listing in five took a price cut.
- The typical sale closed at 96.6% of list, so the average Florida seller is
already accepting less than they asked.
Inventory actually fell 8.1% over the year while days on market stayed high. That combination
usually means sellers are withdrawing rather than buyers returning.
But supply is only half of it. The other half is insurance.
A buyer using a mortgage has to obtain property insurance, and in Florida that has become the
step where deals die. Insurers look hard at roof age, the four-point inspection
and the wind mitigation report. An older roof can complicate insurance and financing for an
ordinary buyer even when nothing is leaking, depending on its condition, remaining useful life,
inspection results and the insurer's underwriting requirements. Prior claims narrow the field
further.
The result is that two identical houses can behave completely differently. The one with a
five-year-old roof gets offers. The one with an eighteen-year-old roof gets viewings and then
silence, and the seller concludes the price is wrong when the real obstacle is that buyers cannot
insure it affordably.
And in a condominium, there is a third thing
Milestone inspection and reserve funding requirements have pushed association assessments up
sharply in many Florida buildings. A unit facing a large special assessment, or in a building
with unresolved inspection findings, can be very hard to finance at all. Buyers who can are often
paying cash, which shrinks the pool and the price at the same time.
What this means if you are the one trying to sell
Cutting the price is the obvious lever and often the wrong one, because it does not fix an
insurance problem or an assessment. The questions worth answering first are these. How old is the
roof? Is there claim history? Is the property in an association, and what does its estoppel
actually say? Would a buyer's lender be able to finance it at all?
If a financed buyer could handle the house, and you have the time to wait out the 73 days and
the money to fix what needs fixing first, list it. Those two conditions are what a listing
actually runs on, and where you have both it will normally beat us.
Where one of them is missing, the comparison is no longer list price against cash price. It is
a cash price now against an unknown number of months of taxes, insurance and association dues on
a house that a financed buyer may never be able to take anyway. In that situation a cash sale is
not the consolation prize. It is frequently the better outcome and sometimes the only one that
actually closes.
Will you tell me which one I am?
Yes, and we will tell you when it is the first one. Send the address, the roof age and the
association name if there is one, and we will say what we think rather than just quoting a
number.